left top navicational image
Navigational image
Browse 2000AD Review
 

2000AD Review Poll
Sinister Dexter - should the gunsharks be permanently retired?
  

About 2000AD Review
 
 
 
 
  Email us

 

Home ¦ Reviews ¦ 2000AD Big Finish CD Reviews

2000AD Review extra 4th August 04

Review by Richmond Clements

Judge Dredd: King and Country
Cover by Cliff Robinson & Chris Blythe
Judge Dredd: For King and Country
By Cavan Scott

Starring:

  • Toby Longworth as Judge Dredd
  • Helen Goldwyn as Brightly Shines
  • Jeremy James as Justin
  • Ian Brooker as Dicky Davidson
  • John Ainsworth as Polearm

Quotable quote: "I have no idea what's happened to my buttless leather chaps."

So, Dredd's back in Brit-Cit again in this one. This time, he is charged with protecting the heir to the British throne, after the Royals are wiped out in a bomb attack.

Why Dredd? I hear you all ask. What the hell has he to do with the British royal family? Well, not wanting to dump a spoiler in this review, even a smallish one, I can tell you the heir is a citizen of the Big Meg. That, I think, is reason enough for Dredd to be forced headlong into a confrontation with the British aristocracy.

In this particular adventure, we are miles away from the Kafkaesque darkness that was employed to great effect in the previous adventure, David Bishop's 'War Crimes'.
Here, we are firmly in the world of broad comedy. Even to the point of a Ronnie Barker voiced news reader delivering the reports in a way familiar to all of us of a certain age. Nice touches abound, from St. Paul McCartney's Cathedral, to the names of the royal corgis.

Cavan Scott has created some terrific comedy characters here. Brightly Shines is a fortysomething, former pop singer, who is on a mission to resurrect her career. I am sure that she is in no way at all based on one of our current pop sensations *Cough* Spears *cough*. Helen Goldwyn also shows herself to be an actor and mimic of no mean talent, as she also handles the role of Queen Betty.

Producer and director John Ainsworth , rather suspiciously I think, has cast himself as Polearm, the faithful Royal robot. I say suspicious, because he's cast himself in a pretty good role. And why not, I say? It's his show after all... But, top comedy honours go to Ian Brooker for Dicky Davidson, a character who brings to mind a certain mahogany-stained television presenter. This character is nothing short of a triumph; he's laugh out loud funny, and the highlight of the production.

Now for what's wrong.

First, a fanboy quibble. According to the back of the box, the story is set in June 2126. However, the citizens of Brit-Cit are enjoying on television, the magnificent spectacle of Slob Idol 2125. Though, on second thoughts, knowing British TV, it's no doubt a repeat...

Another problem, though not a fault of the writing, more a general drawback with this scale of production, is the whodunit aspect of the plot. The main culprit is pretty obvious from the get go. But given that the cast numbers no more than half a dozen characters, this can't be helped.

What you've got here is a frothy light tale. Underneath this though, lurks a far darker animal. Again, I can't say much, as I am not prepared to put in a spoiler. But one strand of narrative here is pretty horrific, if you stop to consider the implications of it. Like the recent Dredd tale 'Meet the Flooks', this has a nice funny surface tale, but if you scrape just a little below the skin, it's not very nice. Scott has, I think, some interesting thoughts on the cult of celebrity, and just what people are prepared to do to get to that status. Listen to this, then think about it.

So with only a couple of caveats, I'd say this is a good addition to the series. Not essential, in the way the previous one was, but a worthy purchase.




This is an unofficial site. All characters and related indicia are © and TM of their respective owners.
Original content (c) 2002 Gavin Hanly (contact 2000AD Review).