|
|
Home
¦ Reviews ¦ Progs
1304 - 1309 : Prog 1309

 |
|
Prog 1309 - 18 September
2002
Cover by Jim Baikie
A cover that
certainly makes an impact and heralds the return of Jim Baikie to Dredd. But don't
celebrate too soon - check out the Dredd review below for the reason...
The input page
makes a full page return this issue, with two notable complaints about the new
(or more correctly, old) direction that Rogue Trooper is taking. Hopefully, they'll
start to listen and kick start the character some more. Not much else apart from
some mobile phone Dredd games - if we find any further info about these, we'll
post a link.
|
|
 |
Script:
John Wagner
|
Art:
Jim Baikie
|
|
Letters:
Tom Frame
|
|
|
|
AN EVERYDAY
DISASTER
Synopsis: A
group of juves launch a rocket at a floating bus - causing it to crash into Nicole
Kidman Block. Dredd, arresting perps nearby, is on the scene, as the building
quickly dissolves into chaos. Dress helps with evacuation as the holocaust squad
moves in - but is soon lost in the heat. Dredd narrowly escapes, saving an orphaned
baby, as the block tumbles down.
The juves are
arrested, with an estimated body count of 14,782 - as everything quickly returns
to normal, with judges at the scene asking people to "Move along now! Nothing
to see here!"
|
|
Review:
Well...where to start? Not quite sure what Wagner's trying to do here, but this
is quite clearly aimed and timed at the anniversary of September 11th. Is it just
a simple: "in the future, large death counts won't mean a thing"? Or
does this represent his backlash to the incessant media coverage of 911? Frankly
neither comes off well - and the story just seems a bit cheap and tasteless. A
shame, as we've come to expect better satire from Wagner.
Now for the art.
First it's great to see Jim Baikie back on art chores, but then you take a look
at the art. Was this drawn in a tea break? The art looks rushed and unfinished,
and drawn with cheap marker pens. Take a look at the crashing "bus"
on page 1. It looks like an unfinished pencil layout! And while it's nice to see
some watercolour art back in 2000 AD, again, this looks garish and splashed on.
Baikie's panel layouts are certainly clear and well composed, but it really looks
like he didn't have time, or wasn't inclined to give much care to this job. Very
disappointing, especially when compared with his recent Tomorrow Stories work.
|
|
 |
Script:
Simon Spurrier
|
Art:
Richard Elson
|
|
Letters:
Annie Parkhouse
|
|
|
| Part
2 - Before Your Eyes
Synopsis: Maliss
and Gir confront a big and nasty alien, which escapes after killing an arachniim
and knocking Gir down - leaving no traces behind except for the body. Later, back
at base, an avatar manifests suggestting further unrest in the "deviant£
population. Later, back on patrol, Maliis and two other enforcers are surrounded
by knife-weilding "deviants."
|
|
Review:
The story shows promise with a couple of intriguing ideas (such as the avatar
and Malliss' baby held in stasis. The art is also on top form, clearly rendering
the future world, with some nice panel layout. I'm finding the story curiously
unengaging though - but will persevere a few more issues before handing down judgement.
However, I will say that I'm finding the use of the word "shiv" instead
of "shit" and "vuck" instead of "fuck" to be extraordinarily
irritating. The use of the word "vuck" in particular calls attention
to itself, and detracts from the story. It just seems like lazy writing.
|
|
 |
Script:
Dan Abnett
|
Art:
Steve Parkhouse
|
|
Letters:
Ellie De Ville
|
Colour:
Chris Blythe
|
|
| Deaky
Poobar. We Hardly Knew Ye. Part 3.
Synopsis: Still
in England, Sinister and Dexter are caught between the police and the mob - both
considerably tooled up. The "go off road" as the two groups meet and
carnage ensues. Finally they reach "Crater Manchester" and get Deaky
Poobar to his final rest. Upon which they discover that Deaky's other name is
that of gunshark "Genghis Carnage" and that the Poobar clan are waiting
outside to take revenge...
|
|
Review:
Brilliant artwork and a suitably insane storyline have made this Sinister Dexter
series a joy. Hopefully Steve Parkhouse will draw more Sinister Dexter strips
from now on, as he's settled into a decent portrayal of the duo.
|
|
 |
Script:
C Clayton, C Dows
|
Art:
L Campbell, L Townsend
|
|
Letters:
Ellie De Ville
|
Colour:
Gary Caldwell
|
|
| Part
9
Synopsis: Last
Episode. Bison (as Charisma) launches after Esposito, but is stopped by Charisma
(as Bison). Who then kills Esposito. Charisma is about to kill Swagger, but Bison
threatens to shoot her. Charisma says Bison won't pull the trigger, as he needs
his body back. Bison shoots Charisma anyway, leaving a VERY big hole in him, and
him in Charisma's body. Last line: "You're right. I AM a good cop. No matter
HOW I look".
|
|
Review:
So the series comes to an end - and despite pretty good artwork has added little
to the 2000 AD canon. The decision to go for gritty violence was unfortunate,
as the length of the story (about 45 pages in total) did not allow for enough
character development to make you care about who was getting shot/beaten up next.
There was a considerable opportunity for satire from this bodyswap premise - but
none of it was taken up on. So in summary, a wasted opportunity, and one that
does not deserve a second series without a major overhaul.
|
|
 |
Script:
Gordon Rennie
|
Pencils:
Mike Collins
|
|
Letters:
Tom Frame
|
Inks:
David Roach
|
|
| Lions:
Part 2
Synopsis: Conclusion.
A few Souther survivors go up against a horde of invading Nagan Nort Troopers.
We are given a potted history on some of them - before they die. Eventually everyone
- Norts and Southers are wiped out - and Rouge et al believe they were all bait
to bring out the Nagan Brigade.
|
|
Review:
An improvement this issue, as the last moments of each of the southers is handled
well, as you understand what brought them to Nu Earth in the first place. It's
only when Rennie tries to explain Rogue's motivation, that you see the problem
- "He fights because it's the only thing he knows". This emphasises
the problem with the current Rogue Trooper stories. We know Rogue catches up with
the Traitor General, so what else can he be used for? He doesn't work as a catalyst
in the same way that Dredd does, and even Dredd has gained a more rounded character
these days. Perhaps longer stories would enable a new plot thread to be laid out,
and build on the "Rogue dying" device that was introduced and dropped
a few issues back. Until then, this character's a waste of space.
|
|
Best Story:
Sinister Dexter - easily.
|
|